By Michelle R. Rodriguez, Esq. of Wright, Finlay & Zak, LLP
Foreclosing in California on one piece of property is relatively straightforward. But, when a foreclosure involves multiple parcels of property, two questions arise: in what order should the parcels be foreclosed, and may they be foreclosed together as one or sold separately? The answers depend on several factors, including but not limited to, whether the foreclosure is judicial or non-judicial, how the debt is secured, whether separate parcels are encumbered by separate deeds of trust, or a single deed of trust encumbers multiple parcels.
Non-Judicial Foreclosure
For non-judicial foreclosures involving multiple properties, several legal principles can dictate the order and method of sale.
- Civil Code § 2924g(a)(4) prohibits bundling properties for the purpose of sale and requires that each property be bid on separately, unless the deed of trust or mortgage requires otherwise. This issue often arises when foreclosing on a construction loan secured by subdivided parcels.
- Civil Code § 2924g(b) allows a third party who claims a portion of the property may require that portion to be sold separately, and that the trustor, if present at the sale, may direct the order in which parcels are sold where they may be sold to advantage separately. It is questionable whether a junior lienholder qualifies as a “third party” – they might. But they have a stronger argument for selling separately the parcel that their lien is on in Civil Code §2899, which is discussed in more depth below.
- Civil Code § 2924g(b) further provides that, where the property lies in two or more counties, a sale of all of the property may take place in any one of the counties in which the property or a portion of it is located. The situation may arise where the properties are in different states. Since the laws of the state in which property is located govern the foreclosure, then the two properties should be sold separately in the state in which the individual parcel is located. Care must be taken because in some circumstances when a foreclosure takes place in another state, the one form of action rule (Code of Civil Procedure § 726) could apply, and also anti-deficiency laws may apply. It is advisable to seek the advice of counsel prior to starting a foreclosure when there is multi-state collateral. It is likewise a good idea to seek the advice of local counsel when making the loan, to take the foreclosure issues into consideration when underwriting the loan.
- As discussed in more detail below, impacted third parties can dictate the order of sale under the equity doctrine of Marshalling.
- Where separate parcels are encumbered by separate deeds of trust, the lender may foreclose on each one separately, and doing so does not violate the anti-deficiency rules. (Dreyfuss v. Union Bank, 24 Cal. 4th 400 (2000)) Indeed, the loans must be foreclosed separately unless the deed of trust provides otherwise.
Marshalling
Marshalling, in the lending context, refers to determining the order in which loan collateral will be sold at a foreclosure sale or sales. The deed of trust may set out the marshalling terms, or those terms may appear in a separate agreement. The deed of trust may also contain a borrower’s waiver of the right to marshal the collateral. Failure to include marshaling terms or a waiver doesn’t necessarily mean that the borrower or a third party automatically controls the marshaling. Rather, the borrower or a third party could give instructions regarding the marshaling if the lender doesn’t include marshaling terms and/or a borrower waiver of marshaling.
Senior versus junior liens. Where a senior lienholder holds liens on several parcels while others hold subordinate liens or have acquired individual parcels, the equitable doctrine of marshalling of assets governs the order of resort. Civil Code section 2899, quoted in Commonwealth Land Title Co. v. Kornbluth, 175 Cal. App. 3d 518, 220 Cal. Rptr. 774 (Ct. App. 1985), directs a senior lienholder — if it can do so without risk of loss to itself or injustice to others, and on the demand of any interested party — to resort to the collateral in a set order: first to property subject to its exclusive lien, then to property subject to the fewest subordinate liens, and, among parcels equally situated, to untransferred property, then property transferred without consideration, and finally property transferred for value in the inverse order of transfer.
The related doctrine of inverse order of alienation provides that, where a debtor has successively conveyed separate parcels subject to a lien, the parcels are sold in the reverse order in which the debtor alienated them, with each grantee entitled to insist that property still held by the debtor be sold first. (Id.) Rights are fixed by reference to the time the debtor alienated each parcel, not the time of any later resale, and the doctrine binds only purchasers who took with notice of the prior conveyances. (Id.)
A corollary protects secondarily liable parcels when the lender releases primary collateral. Under the rule of Blood v. Munn, as applied in Commonwealth Land Title Co. v. Kornbluth, 175 Cal. App. 3d 518, 220 Cal. Rptr. 774 (Ct. App. 1985), if a paramount lienholder, with knowledge of a prior conveyance by the debtor, releases the property primarily chargeable with the debt without the consent of the owners of secondarily liable property, those owners may insist that the value of the released property be credited against the debt. (Id.) Lenders negotiating partial releases across a multi-parcel package should account for this credit rule before letting primary collateral out of the lien.
Judicial Foreclosure of Multiple Parcels
Judicial foreclosure is governed by the one-action rule. Section 726(a) provides that “[t]here can be but one form of action for the recovery of any debt or the enforcement of any right secured by mortgage upon real property,” and authorizes the court to direct the sale of the encumbered property “or so much of the real property or estate for years as may be necessary.” (Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 726) The California Supreme Court reads this provision as embodying two related rules: a “one-action” rule, under which a secured creditor may bring only one lawsuit to enforce its security interest and collect its debt, and a “security-first” rule, under which the creditor must resort to its security before reaching the debtor’s unencumbered assets. (Sec. Pac. Nat’l Bank v. Wozab, 51 Cal. 3d 991, 800 P.2d 557 (1990)) The rule serves two fundamental purposes: preventing a multiplicity of suits against the debtor, and requiring exhaustion of the security before resorting to the debtor’s other assets. (Id.)
Where a single debt is secured by multiple parcels, section 726 affords the debtor two distinct protections. First, the debtor may compel the creditor to include all of the security in a single judicial foreclosure action by raising section 726 as an affirmative defense. (Walker v. Cmty. Bank, 10 Cal. 3d 729, 518 P.2d 329 (1974)) Second, even if the debtor fails to raise that defense and allows the creditor to foreclose on part of the security and obtain a deficiency judgment, the debtor may later invoke the “sanction” aspect of section 726 to bar the creditor from thereafter foreclosing — whether judicially or by power of sale — on the omitted security, on the theory that the creditor has waived it. (Id.)
The sanction operates automatically, and harshly. When a creditor “fail[s] to include the real property and thereby fail[s] to exhaust all security before obtaining a deficiency judgment, it automatically trigger[s] the sanction aspect of section 726 and thereby los[es] all security rights in the real property.” (Id.) The waiver takes effect regardless of whether the omitted parcel is still owned by the debtor or has passed to a successor in interest. (Id.) Put differently, “if a creditor has multiple security interests for a debt and proceeds against less than all of them in a judicial foreclosure action, in which he obtains a deficiency judgment, he cannot thereafter seek to foreclose the excluded security.” (Sec. Pac. Nat’l Bank v. Wozab, 51 Cal. 3d 991, 800 P.2d 557 (1990))
The debt itself survives — only the security is lost. In Sec. Pac. Nat’l Bank v. Wozab, the court explained that a creditor who fails to comply with section 726 keeps its judgment on the underlying debt but loses its preferred position as a secured creditor, in whole or in part, and is reduced to the status of an unsecured creditor — a drastic sanction for the lender. (Id.) For a lender holding several valuable parcels, the practical lesson is unforgiving: name and pursue every parcel in the one action, or risk losing the liens on whatever is left out.
Several statutory features accommodate a single judicial foreclosure that captures all of the collateral.
Multi-county parcels. Where the mortgaged property consists of a single parcel, or of two or more parcels situated in two or more counties, the court may in its judgment direct the whole to be sold in one of the counties, “with like effect[] as if the whole of the property were situated in that county.” (Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 726) This permits one judgment and one consolidated sale process even when the collateral is geographically dispersed.
Sell only what is necessary. The foreclosure decree may direct sale of the encumbered property “or so much of the real property or estate for years as may be necessary” to satisfy the debt. (Cal. Civ. Proc. Code § 726) Once enough has been realized, the remaining parcels need not be sold.
Order of sale where parcels have different owners. Where parcels securing one debt are owned by different parties or carry different subordinate liens, the decree may fix the order of sale to protect junior and secondary interests. In Bechtel v. Wier, 152 Cal. 443, 93 P. 75 (1907), two mortgages on separate properties — one from the principal debtor and one from a surety — secured a single debt, and the decree directed that the principal debtor’s parcel be sold first, with the surety’s parcel sold only for any deficiency remaining. (Id.) This sequencing reflects the surety’s equitable right to have the principal’s property exhausted first. (Id.)
Take-Aways
- Check your deeds of trust to confirm that they contain a waiver-of-marshalling clause, in which the borrower waives the right to determine the order of foreclosure of the collateral and specifically grants the lender the right to marshal the collateral. Note – the waiver does not bar a junior lienholder from asserting the right to marshal assets and direct the order of sale.
- At underwriting, if the order of foreclosure of the collateral is important, consider spelling it out in a separate marshalling agreement. Likewise, if you want the later ability to “bundle” multiple properties for sale, require it in your deed of trust.
- Before granting a partial release, determine whether there are junior lienholders or new owners, and whether you are crediting to the loan the value of the released property.
- Before foreclosing on liens secured by more than one property, determine the structure of the deal: do the parcels secure a single debt, or are there separate notes secured by separate deeds of trust? Absent controlling language in the deed of trust, this determines the order in which the parcels must be sold. In fact, we recommend contacting counsel before foreclosing on loans secured by multiple properties. Doing so can avoid the cost and delay associated with having to restart your foreclosure later. Likewise, its important to discuss with counsel bidding strategies when more than one property is involved.
- In a judicial foreclosure, capture all of the security in one action.
Disclaimer: The above information is intended for information purposes alone and is not intended as legal advice. Please consult with counsel before taking any steps in reliance on any of the information contained herein.
Michelle R. Rodriguez, Esq. is a Partner at Wright, Finlay, Zak. She can be reached at mrodriguez@wrightlegal.net.
Michelle R. Rodriguez, Esq.