By Cathy K. Robinson, Esq. and T. Robert Finlay, Esq.
This article was originally published in the Scotsman Guide.
Most consumer loans amortize over 30 years, leaving a small payment due at the time of maturity. As a result, accepting payments after maturity is usually not an issue. But many business purpose and commercial loans only require interest payments, leaving a large balance due when the loan matures. Rather than immediately foreclose, these lenders often choose to work with the borrower to extend the loan, modify its terms or find other solutions in lieu of foreclosing. Many of those foreclosure prevention alternatives involve accepting partial payments. The question is – when does accepting a post-maturity payment unintentionally extend the term of the loan?
If you service loans with balloon payments, you have almost assuredly faced a situation where the loan has matured, but the borrower fails to remit the full payment amount owed. Instead, you receive a partial payment and are left with two options – reject or accept the payment. Many times, the servicer, generally at the direction of the lender, accepts the partial payment. But, by accepting, have you also inadvertently agreed to extend the loan terms? Moreover, if you accept, do you also need to send a new notice of payment pursuant to Civil Code section 2924i? The answer is found in the interplay between California Civil Code section 2924i and any non-waiver clause contained in the loan documents.
1. Can Acceptance Alone Extend the Loan Terms?
Here’s the typical lawyer answer – it depends! But, before you roll your eyes and think this article is a waste of time, the definitive answer can be found in your Deed of Trust.
Most Deeds of Trust contain anti-waiver provisions which specifically protect the lender in this situation. (Note – if you loan documents do not contain one, they should!) Anti-waiver clauses generally provide that a lender’s failure to enforce its contractual rights in a breach situation shall not constitute a waiver of that breach or the remedies available to the lender. Many also specifically provide that acceptance of late or partial payments does not extend or modify the loan. These clauses are consistently upheld by courts across the nation based on their plain language, but enforcement is based on the parties’ actual conduct, which must be consistent with the anti-waiver clause terms.
Assuming the Deed of Trust contains the appropriate anti-waiver language, the lender’s mere acceptance of a post-maturity partial payment should not extend the loan terms. However, it’s important that the lender’s conduct is consistent with the anti-waiver provision. The following is a non-exclusive list of behavior that could be viewed as waiving the anti-waiver provision:
- Representing orally or in writing that the maturity date has been extended;
- Accepting post-maturity payments for an extended period of time[1];
- Continue sending monthly loan statements showing that a monthly payment is due;
- Charging monthly late charges, sending out reinstatement quotes or otherwise internally accounting for the loan as if it had not matured; and
- Resending a second balloon notice.
2. How Do I Protect Myself?
Accepting partial payments post-maturity while the borrower looks for ways to pay off your loan is a win-win for everyone. The borrower gets more time to sell the property or otherwise payoff the loan, while at the same time avoiding foreclosure. Meanwhile, the lender continues to collect interest on the loan while avoiding the cost of foreclosing.
But lenders need to be careful not to put their ability to foreclose at risk over a few payments. Below are a few tips to avoid getting yourselves in trouble.
- Check to make sure your Deed of Trust has sufficient anti-waiver language. If it does not, use any opportunity you have to add an anti-waiver clause, e.g., when postponing the foreclosure sale, modifying or extending the loan, entering into a forbearance plan, etc.
- Document any post-maturity discussions, making it clear that you are NOT extending the term of the loan or waiving the anti-waiver provision.
- Send the borrower a Reservation of Rights letter after accepting EACH and every post-maturity payment. The ROR letter should specifically advise the borrower that acceptance of the payment is not to be considered a modification of the loan or a waiver of any of the loan terms. This letter would not only cut against any argument by the borrower that the lender intended to modify the loan; but is also strong evidence that the borrower knew the acceptance did not extend the loan term.
- If the lender already sent a Balloon Notice, as required by Civil Code Section 2924i, the lender will be better protected if the ROR letter specifically references that the notice was already sent and that a new notice will not be sent. In addition, think twice before sending a second Balloon Notice. Otherwise, a borrower may argue that sending the second Balloon Notice is evidence that the lender intended to voluntarily extend the due date, otherwise why did the lender send the new notice in the first place.
- Keep a short leash on any post-maturity discussions. The longer the lender accepts post-maturity payments, holds off foreclosing or calling the loan due, the better the borrower’s waiver argument.
- On a related note, if you are extending the maturity of the loan, make sure it’s in writing! In addition, we recommend including certain reaffirmations and releases in the extension agreement.
In sum, accepting one post-maturity payment is unlikely to get the lender in trouble. But, accepting multi payments over an extended period of time without a ROR letter can legitimately mislead the borrower into believing the loan term has been extended.
Disclaimer: The above information is intended for information purposes alone and is not intended as legal advice. Please consult with counsel before taking any steps in reliance on any of the information contained herein.
Cathy K. Robinson, Esq. is a Partner in the California office at Wright Finlay & Zak. She can be reached at crobinson@wrightlegal.net. T. Robert Finaly, Esq. CMA General Counsel and is a Founding Partner of Wright Finlay & Zak. He can be reached at rfinlay@wrightlegal.net.
[1] Note – Repeatedly accepting monthly payments after a non-monetary default, e.g., violation of the due-on-transfer clause, can also be deemed a waiver of the default.
Cathy K. Robinson, Esq.